Business as Usual: FDA Prevents Citizens from Analyzing Their Own DNA

On November 22, the FDA sent a warning letter to to stop its inexpensive ($99 per test) “do-it-yourself” genetic testing service for health screening and ancestry purposes, because consumers could be “misled” and harm themselves by “self-treating.” For example, the FDA posits that an individual who learns they have a predilection for cancer would, as a result, undergo unnecessary preventive surgery, chemotherapy, and other “morbidity-inducing actions.”
The FDA’s argument is, quite clearly, a straw man: of course patients have to obtain medical advice before making major health decisions—it’s not as if consumers can go under the knife without significant medical consultation! The FDA’s true message is clear: because individuals can’t be trusted to make sound health decisions, they don’t have a right to private information on their own DNA.
It’s also worth noting that FDA action against 23andMe was sparked, in part, by a complaint by UnitedHealth Group, the largest publicly traded health insurer. UnitedHealth isn’t exactly an unbiased observer—they want access to information about your DNA. After all, if individuals were allowed to keep their DNA test data private, they wouldn’t have to share their results with insurers who, for example, could use an inherited health risk to deny insurance or charge exorbitant rates.
The FDA’s stance on DIY genetic testing could very well drive up healthcare costs. Besides premiums being raised on those forced to report DNA results to insurance companies, in-office testing is far more expensive. As tests are priced anywhere from $300 to $3,500, this could significantly add to the overall cost of healthcare.

This, of course, should be unconstitutional. However, violation of citizen’s right has become the norm due to special interest groups.

We do, from time to time, have national heroes who effectively deal with government suppression. The CEO of Uber Taxi shows how to do it. Tesla Motors is using similar strategies to bypass car dealer monopolies that suppress competition. 

As Harvard Business Review points out, the healthcare system is in need of total disruption as it suppresses innovation that causing increased deaths in the population. This is one of the reasons that the U.S. healthcare system is number 38 in the world, roughly equivalent to some developing nations. Yet many of our citizens think U.S. healthcare is the best in the world because we spend more money per capita on healthcare than any other nation.

1France France4
2Italy Italy11
3San Marino San Marino21
4 Andorra23
5 Malta37
6Singapore Singapore38
7Spain Spain24
8Oman Oman62
9 Austria6
10Japan Japan13
11 Norway16
12Portugal Portugal27
13 Monaco12
14 Greece30
15Iceland Iceland14
16 Luxembourg5
17Netherlands Netherlands9
18United Kingdom United Kingdom26
19Republic of Ireland Ireland25
20Switzerland Switzerland2
21 Belgium15
22Colombia Colombia49
23Sweden Sweden7
24Cyprus Cyprus39
25Germany Germany3
26Saudi Arabia Saudi Arabia63
27United Arab Emirates United Arab Emirates35
28Israel Israel19
29Morocco Morocco99
30Canada Canada10
31Finland Finland18
32Australia Australia17
33 Chile44
34Argentina Argentina15
35 Denmark8
36 Dominica70
37Costa Rica Costa Rica50
38United States United States1

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *